turash/concept/monetisation/product-offerings.md

# Product Offerings & Value Propositions

## Overview

Turash delivers value through three core product categories: resource matching, business discovery, and compliance/reporting. Each product is designed to address specific industrial symbiosis challenges while creating measurable economic and environmental impact.

## 1. Core Resource Matching Products

### Heat Match Report

**Positioning**: Technical and economic analysis for waste heat recovery opportunities.

**Deliverable**:
- Technical feasibility analysis with temperature compatibility (±10°C tolerance)
- Economic ROI calculations including payback periods (2-5 years)
- Geographic and infrastructure feasibility assessment
- CO₂ emissions avoided quantification
- Regulatory permit requirements checklist

**Value Proposition**:
- Average €5k-12k annual savings per successful connection
- 20-30% conversion rate from proposal to implementation
- Addresses 40-60% of industrial energy waste potential

**Usage Patterns**:
- Frequency: 1-2 matches per facility annually
- Implementation probability: ML-based scoring (0-100%)
- Status pipeline: Proposed → Accepted → Technical Review → Economic Analysis → Legal Review → Capex Planning → Implementation

### Match Lifecycle & Status Tracking

**Positioning**: End-to-end project management for industrial symbiosis exchanges.

**Key Features**:
- **Status Pipeline**: Comprehensive tracking from initial proposal through operational phase
- **Blocked Deal Intelligence**: Structured analysis of stalled/capex issues, legal concerns, and implementation barriers
- **Success Probability Scoring**: ML-driven implementation likelihood prediction
- **Failure Learning**: Systematic capture of non-implementation reasons to improve matching algorithm

**Value Creation**:
- Platform earns on intent, not just success
- Data-driven improvement of matching accuracy
- Reduced transaction friction through structured processes

### Industrial Symbiosis Zone Map

**Positioning**: Geographic optimization for multi-party resource networks.

**Deliverable**:
- Interactive visualization of recommended industrial clusters
- Multi-party economic optimization using MILP algorithms
- Shared infrastructure cost-benefit analysis (district heating, water treatment)
- Cluster formation recommendations based on resource complementarity

**Value Proposition**:
- Multi-facility optimization vs. pairwise matching
- 15-25% additional value through shared infrastructure
- Municipal policy support and new facility siting guidance

**Revenue Model**: Premium feature in Business/Enterprise tiers with municipal licensing potential.

## 2. Business Discovery Products

### Local Partners Feed

**Positioning**: Real-time B2B opportunity discovery within industrial ecosystems.

**Features**:
- Proximity-based business directory
- Resource capabilities mapping
- Service provider marketplace integration
- Non-resource opportunity matching (suppliers, customers, partners)

**Value Proposition**:
- €5k-15k annual soft value through improved business relationships
- 85% of platform engagement occurs here
- Network effects driver for paid tier conversion

**Engagement Metrics**:
- Daily usage by 70% of active users
- Primary driver of organic growth and word-of-mouth referrals

### Supplier Network Map

**Positioning**: Context-aware B2B discovery with relationship visualization.

**Features**:
- Graph-based supplier network visualization
- Supply chain risk analysis and diversification recommendations
- Alternative supplier identification
- Relationship strength and reliability scoring

**Value Proposition**:
- Procurement optimization and supplier risk mitigation
- Strategic supplier network management
- Competitive advantage through enhanced supply chain resilience

**Target Users**: Procurement managers, operations directors, supply chain executives.

### Service Match Dashboard

**Positioning**: Professional service provider connections for industrial operations.

**Features**:
- Service provider profiles with ratings and reviews
- Availability scheduling and booking integration
- Service history and performance tracking
- Quality and reliability metrics

**Service Categories**:
- Maintenance and technical services
- Engineering and consulting
- Environmental and compliance services
- Specialized industrial services

**Value Proposition**:
- Quality service provider discovery
- Cost optimization through competitive bidding
- Emergency service access and rapid response capabilities

**Revenue Model**: 10-20% commission on service transactions + subscription access fees.

## 3. Compliance & Reporting Products

### ESG Impact Report (MRV-Compliant)

**Positioning**: Auditable circularity and sustainability metrics for regulatory compliance.

**Core Calculators**:
- **Heat Recovery**: GHG Protocol-compliant CO₂ avoidance (€/t CO₂ = 0.000089 × heat_kWh × grid_intensity_factor)
- **Material Reuse**: ISO 14064 waste diversion tracking with double-counting prevention
- **Water Recycling**: EU Water Framework Directive compliance metrics

**Compliance Features**:
- **Audit Trail**: Complete source data, calculation formulas, and assumption documentation
- **Double-Counting Prevention**: Attribution tracking (company/city/platform)
- **Sign-off Process**: Self-certification with third-party verification options
- **Regulatory Alignment**: CSRD, EU Taxonomy, and GHG Protocol compliance

**Value Proposition**:
- Regulatory compliance risk reduction
- Competitive positioning through demonstrated circularity commitment
- Grant application support with auditable metrics

**Revenue Model**: Included in Business/Enterprise tiers (+15-20% ARPA uplift) with premium add-on for Basic tier.

### Carbon Accounting API (Informational)

**Positioning**: Planning and internal reporting estimates for carbon reduction initiatives.

**Features**:
- Real-time CO₂ savings estimates from resource exchanges
- Calculation methodology transparency
- Benchmarking against industry averages
- Trend analysis and forecasting capabilities

**Regulatory Position**:
- Explicitly informational/unverified
- Partners handle verification for official credits
- Clear disclaimers about estimation nature

**Usage Cases**:
- Internal planning and decision-making
- Preliminary grant applications
- Trend analysis and goal setting
- Benchmarking and peer comparison

**Revenue Model**: €5-15/t CO₂ calculation fee with referral fees for verification partners.

### Regulatory Compliance Dashboard

**Positioning**: Comprehensive tracking of permits, certifications, and regulatory requirements.

**Features**:
- Permit expiration tracking and renewal reminders
- Industry-specific regulatory requirement mapping
- Compliance status reporting and gap analysis
- Document management and audit preparation

**Value Proposition**:
- Risk mitigation through proactive compliance management
- Reduced regulatory fines and penalties
- Operational efficiency through automated tracking

**Target Users**: Operations managers, compliance officers, environmental managers.

## 4. Shared OPEX Products

### Shared OPEX Report

**Positioning**: Group buying opportunities for recurring operational costs.

**Features**:
- Consolidated service provider quotes
- Volume discount negotiation coordination
- Split billing and payment processing
- Multi-facility cost optimization

**Service Categories**:
- Waste collection and disposal
- Maintenance and service contracts
- Utility procurement (energy, water)
- Insurance and risk management

**Value Proposition**:
- 10-20% cost reduction through volume purchasing
- Reduced administrative burden through coordinated procurement
- Access to better pricing through aggregated demand

**Revenue Model**: 3-5% commission on deal value + subscription access fees.

## 5. Product Monetization Strategy

### Freemium Architecture

**Free Tier Purpose**:
- Network effects driver (70% of total users)
- Organic growth through word-of-mouth
- Value demonstration and proof-of-concept
- Conversion funnel entry point

**Paid Tier Value Ladders**:
- **Basic Tier**: Core resource matching and ROI analysis
- **Business Tier**: Advanced analytics, service marketplace, facilitator support
- **Enterprise Tier**: White-label, custom integrations, dedicated support

### Outcome-Based Revenue

**Transaction Fee Alignment**:
- Lead fees earned on introduction facilitation
- Success fees earned on implementation completion
- Commission-based service marketplace revenue
- Outcome alignment ensures platform success incentives

### Municipal Value Capture

**Public Dashboard Strategy**:
- City-wide resource flow visualization
- Policy support and economic development tools
- CO₂ tracking and sustainability metrics
- Free access drives business adoption and engagement

## 6. Product Development Priorities

### Phase 1: Core Matching (Year 1)
- Heat exchange matching engine
- Basic economic calculations
- Partner introduction facilitation
- Essential compliance reporting

### Phase 2: Ecosystem Expansion (Year 2)
- Multi-resource matching (water, waste, materials)
- Service marketplace and facilitator network
- Advanced analytics and scenario planning
- Municipal dashboard and licensing

### Phase 3: Enterprise Scale (Year 3)
- White-label and custom integrations
- Advanced compliance and MRV features
- Multi-site management capabilities
- API ecosystem and third-party integrations

## 7. Success Metrics by Product

### Resource Matching
- **Match Quality**: 25-35% implementation rate
- **Economic Value**: €5k-12k average savings per match
- **Time to Implementation**: 3-6 months average

### Business Discovery
- **Engagement Rate**: Daily usage by 70% of active users
- **Conversion Value**: €5k-15k annual relationship value
- **Network Density**: 60%+ local clustering within 5km radius

### Compliance & Reporting
- **Adoption Rate**: 80%+ of Business/Enterprise customers
- **Audit Success**: 100% verification pass rate
- **Value Capture**: 15-20% ARPA uplift from compliance features

---

*Product offerings designed around industrial symbiosis realities: complex, high-value exchanges requiring technical, economic, and regulatory support.*